While the death penalty may be considered a deterrent, there is no guarantee that the person incarcerated (unless the murder is seen by a reliable witness) is guilty. You've only got to look at the number of criminal cases that have been overturned since DNA testing has become available to know that the justice system is flawed.
This book is thought provoking and would make a good book club read.
Book club questions/reading guide here
Note: You can click on the Amazon widget below to purchase the book from Amazon.